Alma 23: Seven Places Named, Then One Verse for Everyone Else

By David Whitaker

The Alma 22 post ended on the proclamation, the one verse 27 says the king sent through the land without saying what was in it. Alma 23 opens with the contents, and they turn out to be a report more than a quotation. No one in this chapter is quoted. The king's decree comes to us in the narrator's words, and so do the king's reasons.

I'm leaving most of the chapter's eighteen verses alone and staying with four stretches of it.

Verses 1 to 3: what the decree forbids

The decree protects "Ammon, or Aaron, or Omner, or Himni, nor either of their brethren who should go forth preaching the word of God, in whatsoever place they should be, in any part of their land" (Alma 23:1). Verse 2 then gets specific. Nobody is to lay hands on them "to bind them, or to cast them into prison," nor spit on them, nor smite them, nor cast them out of their synagogues, nor scourge them, nor cast stones at them. I count seven.

Of the seven, Alma 20:30 already reports several happening to Aaron and his brothers, saying the people "had cast them out, and had smitten them, and had driven them from house to house, and from place to place," and that in Middoni "they were taken and cast into prison, and bound with strong cords, and kept in prison for many days." Verse 29 of the same chapter has their skins "worn exceedingly because of being bound with strong cords." Alma 21:13 says again that Aaron and some of his brothers "were taken and cast into prison." So binding, prison and smiting are reported outright, and casting out is reported too, though as being driven from houses and places, not out of synagogues. Aaron does leave a synagogue in Alma 21:11, but the text has him departing because the people "would not hear his words," not because anyone threw him out. Spitting, scourging and stones don't appear in Alma 20 or 21 at all. A decree can list what hasn't happened yet along with what has.

The grant at the end of verse 2 is a single clause: "free access to their houses, and also their temples, and their sanctuaries."

Verse 3 gives the purpose, and the narrator gives it, not the king. The reason first: "for the king had been converted unto the Lord, and all his household." Then what the decree was for.

that the word of God might have no obstruction, but that it might go forth throughout all the land, that his people might be convinced concerning the wicked traditions of their fathers, and that they might be convinced that they were all brethren, and that they ought not to murder, nor to plunder, nor to steal, nor to commit adultery, nor to commit any manner of wickedness.

Alma 23:3

Set against each other, the prohibitions in verse 2 are about what the king's people may not do to these men. The purposes in verse 3 are about what those people should end up believing: that their fathers' traditions were wicked, that they were "all brethren," that they "ought not to murder." A decree can keep a hand off a preacher. It can't convince anybody of anything, and the verse says only that the decree lets the word go forth so that the people "might be convinced." The conviction is left to the preaching, which verse 4 shows Aaron and his brothers doing "from city to city, and from one house of worship to another."

There is an earlier grant of liberty to set beside this one. Alma 21:22 reports Lamoni declaring to his people "that they might have the liberty of worshiping the Lord their God according to their desires, in whatsoever place they were in, if it were in the land which was under the reign of king Lamoni." Lamoni's liberty stops at the edge of his own reign. The decree in Alma 23:1 runs "in any part of their land." Both are reported by the narrator, and the second is wider.

Verses 8 to 15: the converted places, and who isn't on the list

The next stretch reads like a roll call introduced by "Now, these are they who were converted unto the Lord," and then come the places: the land of Ishmael, the land of Middoni, the city of Nephi, then four in verse 12, which are the land of Shilom, the land of Shemlon, the city of Lemuel and the city of Shimnilom. Seven in all. Verse 13 calls the whole list "the cities of the Lamanites which were converted unto the Lord," though a few of them are called lands a verse earlier, and it adds that "they were all Lamanites." In verse 15 the narrator says "we have named all the cities of the Lamanites in which they did repent and come to the knowledge of the truth."

Between those two sits verse 14, a single verse for what the list leaves out.

And the Amalekites were not converted, save only one; neither were any of the Amulonites; but they did harden their hearts, and also the hearts of the Lamanites in that part of the land wheresoever they dwelt, yea, and all their villages and all their cities.

Alma 23:14

"Save only one" reads as one Amalekite, who isn't named, and the chapter never comes back to him. The Amulonites don't get an exception at all.

In verse 14 the Amalekites and Amulonites harden their own hearts and "also the hearts of the Lamanites in that part of the land." So the chapter that says seven places converted also says there are Lamanites who didn't, in villages and cities it doesn't list. Alma 21:3 had already said it: "the Lamanites of themselves were sufficiently hardened, but the Amalekites and the Amulonites were still harder," so that they "did cause the Lamanites that they should harden their hearts." Aaron met the same wall when he preached to the Amalekites in their synagogue in Alma 21:4 to 10.

Alma 24:1 opens with "the Amalekites and the Amulonites and the Lamanites who were in the land of Amulon, and also in the land of Helam, and who were in the land of Jerusalem," who "had not been converted," and who "were stirred up by the Amalekites and by the Amulonites to anger against their brethren."

Verses 16 and 17: the name comes last

Everything above happens before anyone has a name, and verse 16 says "the king and those who were converted were desirous that they might have a name, that thereby they might be distinguished from their brethren." So the desire belongs to the king and to the converted together. Then: "the king consulted with Aaron and many of their priests, concerning the name that they should take upon them."

Verse 17 then says "they called their names Anti-Nephi-Lehies," and the subject of that sentence is "they." The verse doesn't say the king chose it, or Aaron, or that someone proposed it and the rest agreed. It says they were called by it and "were no more called Lamanites."

The chapter doesn't tell us what the name means, and I won't guess. What the text gives me is the order. They were converted first, the king went to Aaron and priests second, and the name arrived third.

Verse 18 and the curse

In verse 18 the chapter wraps up. "They began to be a very industrious people; yea, and they were friendly with the Nephites; therefore, they did open a correspondence with them, and the curse of God did no more follow them" (Alma 23:18). The sentence doesn't tell us what the curse was, how it followed anyone or how it stopped. Other passages in the book mention a curse, and readers put this verse next to them, but that is a link readers make. Alma 23 doesn't make it, and the verse itself gives industrious, friendly, a correspondence opened.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who chose the name Anti-Nephi-Lehi?

The chapter doesn't say. Verse 16 has the king and the converted wanting a name and the king consulting "Aaron and many of their priests," and verse 17 says "they called their names" it.

Did every Lamanite in Alma 23 convert?

No. Verses 9 to 13 give the converted places and verse 13 says "they were all Lamanites," and verse 14 says the Amalekites and Amulonites hardened "the hearts of the Lamanites in that part of the land." Alma 24:1 names Lamanites who "had not been converted."

How many people converted?

Verse 5 says "thousands" and gives no number. The "more than a thousand" of Alma 24:27 is a separate count of people who joined after the attack in the next chapter, so it shouldn't be added to it.

What does "the curse of God did no more follow them" mean?

Verse 18 doesn't say. It's the last clause of a sentence about industry, friendship with the Nephites and an opened correspondence, and the chapter gives no description of the curse or of what ended it.

Alma 24 picks up with the people verse 14 left off the list.

— D.

Alma 23: Seven Places Named, Then One Verse for Everyone Else