D&C 118: A Staffing Plan With an Official Notice at the End
I think D&C 118 is a staffing plan, and I mean that kindly. Six verses of who does what and by when, written by someone who expects the work to get done.
In September I opened my calendar and found an all-day block on a Tuesday in early December. The title read "Settlement cutover, D. Whitaker primary." Nobody had asked me, and I accepted it anyway, because declining would have meant a conversation. The meeting where a person finally explained what the cutover involved came three weeks later, on a Thursday, in a room with a broken projector. The date was fixed long before I knew the job.
Verse 5 reminded me of that, a day set on the calendar months before anyone could see how it would go. The comparison only goes so far, since I was annoyed and nothing in the chapter says the Twelve were. But it's why I went through the chapter the way you'd go through a schedule, one line at a time.
What does D&C 118 actually say, and when?
Every one of the six verses is built around a "Let." Let a conference be held, let my servant Thomas remain, let the residue continue, let them depart. The heading on the section dates it to July 8, 1838, at Far West, so everything in it is about what comes next.
The time words come one to a verse, mostly. Verse 1 says "immediately." Verse 2 says "for a season." Verse 3 says "from that hour" and, at the very end of the same verse, "from henceforth." Verse 4 says "next spring." Verse 5 gives an actual day, which is a different kind of time word altogether.
Let them take leave of my saints in the city of Far West, on the twenty-sixth day of April next, on the building-spot of my house, saith the Lord. (D&C 118:5)
A day and a place, given a little over nine months ahead. The chapter doesn't say why the twenty-sixth, but D&C 115 comes close to saying it for it. I wrote about that section earlier this month in The Name Gets Two Verses and the House Gets Nine. It was given at Far West on April 26, 1838, it commands a house there, and it says "in one year from this day let them re-commence laying the foundation of my house" (D&C 115:11). A year from that day is April 26, 1839. So the leave-taking in verse 5 is set for the same day and the same ground as the foundation, and I take the house in both to be the same one, though neither section points at the other.
Put the verses in order and the plan has a shape. Verses 1 and 2 are for now: hold the meeting, organize the quorum, leave one man where he is. Verses 3 and 4 look further out, first a promise for the families and then the crossing. The fifth verse pins the departure to a day, and verse 6 goes back to the beginning to fill the vacancies, this time with names.
Why does verse 1 ask for the procedure before the people?
Look at what verse 1 hands over. A conference, an organized Twelve and men to be appointed "to supply the place of those who are fallen." Three steps, and the verse asks for the appointing before it says whom. The replacements aren't named until verse 6.
Let my servant John Taylor, and also my servant John E. Page, and also my servant Wilford Woodruff, and also my servant Willard Richards, be appointed to fill the places of those who have fallen, and be officially notified of their appointment. (D&C 118:6)
"Officially notified."
The verse sets down that appointment and notice are two separate things, and the second one is written into the revelation. A man named by revelation still gets an official notice. I'd have thought that line too ordinary to be in a revelation.
The men being replaced get the same handling at both ends of the chapter. Verse 1 says "those who are fallen" and verse 6 says "those who have fallen," with nothing about who they were or what they did. The chapter needs them only as places to be filled.
Why is Thomas told to stay?
Verse 2 is the shortest instruction in the chapter. "Let my servant Thomas remain for a season in the land of Zion, to publish my word." The text gives a first name and nothing else. The editors of the Joseph Smith Papers identify him as Thomas B. Marsh, and I'm relying on them for that.
Then verse 3 sends "the residue" out preaching, and verse 4 sends them over the great waters. One man is held back and given a different job, publishing, and a different place, Zion. Nobody is told he's the lesser one, though the others are told to preach and he is told to publish. Verses 4 and 5 point to a spring and then to a day. Verse 2 gives only "for a season," and I'd have liked to know how long that was.
The promise in verse 3 has an "if" in it
Let the residue continue to preach from that hour, and if they will do this in all lowliness of heart, in meekness and humility, and long-suffering, I, the Lord, give unto them a promise that I will provide for their families; and an effectual door shall be opened for them, from henceforth. (D&C 118:3)
Two things are in that sentence. A promise, that families will be provided for and that a door will open. And a condition, a way of preaching: lowliness of heart, meekness, humility, long-suffering. They're all words about manner, and the promise follows from the manner.
The families matter because verse 4 sends their fathers across an ocean, in the very next verse. Read together, 3 and 4 are one thought: you will go a long way from home, and the people at home will be provided for if you go the right way. The promise comes first, so it is already in place when the departure is named.
By the spring in verse 5 the Saints had been driven out of Missouri. The accounts I've read agree that some of the Twelve met at the temple site that day and took leave there. They differ on the details, so I'll leave the details to them. The text itself is an instruction, and "Let them take leave" is worded as one.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is D&C 118 about?
It's a short revelation, dated July 1838 at Far West, Missouri, and it tells the Church to hold a conference, organize the Twelve and appoint four men to fill places left empty. It also sends the Twelve on a mission over the great waters the next spring, after taking leave of the Saints on a named day.
Who are the four men named in verse 6?
John Taylor, John E. Page, Wilford Woodruff and Willard Richards. The Church's student manual notes that Taylor and Woodruff later became Church presidents and that Page later left the Church. That comes from the manual, not the verses.
Who is "Thomas" in verse 2?
The verse gives only the first name. The Joseph Smith Papers editors identify him as Thomas B. Marsh, who was then president of the Quorum of the Twelve.
Does the revelation say who the fallen men were?
No. Verse 1 says "those who are fallen" and verse 6 says "those who have fallen," and the chapter doesn't name them or describe their faults. I'd be careful with any lesson that starts by guessing.
Did the Twelve leave on that day?
Some of them took leave at the temple site that day, by the accounts I read, but the mission itself got under way later in 1839. The sources disagree on the details. The chapter was given months before, so it can only say what was to happen.
What I still don't like about it
Verse 3 gives me a promise and a condition and no way to check the condition. "All lowliness of heart" isn't something I can look up in myself, and the verse follows it with three more words of the same kind. I'd like a plainer test. The verse is clear about what comes if they do it, and it leaves the man doing the preaching to decide whether he has.
— D.