"Numbers 2: The Tabernacle Goes After Reuben and Before Ephraim"

By David Whitaker

Numbers 2 gives each of the four camps one paragraph, and each paragraph does two jobs. It says which side the camp pitches on, then where it falls in line when the people move. Judah is on the east side (verse 3) and "shall first set forth" (verse 9). Reuben is on the south (verse 10) and goes "in the second rank" (verse 16). Ephraim is on the west (verse 18) and goes "in the third rank" (verse 24). Dan is on the north (verse 25) and goes "hindmost" (verse 31).

The tabernacle isn't in any of those paragraphs. The chapter puts it in verse 17, between the Reuben paragraph and the Ephraim paragraph.

What verse 17 says, and where it sits

Then the tabernacle of the congregation shall set forward with the camp of the Levites in the midst of the camp: as they encamp, so shall they set forward, every man in his place by their standards.
(Numbers 2:17)

The tabernacle, then, travels after two camps and before two, and by the chapter's own figures that's 337,850 numbered men ahead of it (Judah's 186,400 and Reuben's 151,450) and 265,700 behind (Ephraim's 108,100 and Dan's 157,600). That's the middle of the line if you count camps and not if you count men. The Levites who travel with it were in neither number.

Verse 33 says so directly, "the Levites were not numbered among the children of Israel," and I went through that at some length on Thursday in the post on Numbers 1. What chapter 2 adds is that the people who aren't counted are the ones the counted tribes get arranged around.

Verse 2 puts the distance as "far off about the tabernacle" and leaves it there, with no cubits and no paces. I keep wanting a number the chapter keeps not giving me.

Eleven students and one wrong row

My mother taught piano out of our front room in Bountiful, and every first Saturday in May she held a recital there. In 1989, when I was ten, she had eleven students. My dad borrowed folding chairs from the ward building and brought them over in the station wagon in two trips, and they went in rows facing the piano. The program lay on the piano lid, youngest to oldest, so the first to play was Janelle, who was five.

Her family was in the third row, four seats in from the aisle. Her grandmother moved up to the front row partway through the piece to see her hands. Janelle played "Lightly Row," bowed because my mother had told her to, and then walked back, saw her grandmother in the front, and sat down in the first empty chair she came to, between a man in a sport coat and a woman I didn't know. Her parents were two rows behind her. Her mother half stood up and sat down again. Nobody said anything for the next two students, and my mother, who stood by the piano the whole afternoon, kept the program going. Between the third piece and the fourth she walked over and bent down and said something I couldn't hear, and Janelle got up and went to the third row.

The next May every chair had a strip of masking tape on the back with a family name on it. I thought of that Saturday this week at verse 17, probably because the chapter has two kinds of place going at once, where you pitch and where you walk, and my mother's program only had one of them.

Numbers 10 shows the line

Chapter 2 only says how they would move, and Numbers 10 is where they do. The cloud is taken up on the twentieth day of the second month (10:11), and Judah goes first:

In the first place went the standard of the camp of the children of Judah according to their armies: and over his host was Nahshon the son of Amminadab.
(Numbers 10:14)

Issachar and Zebulun are named in verses 15 and 16, and then:

And the tabernacle was taken down; and the sons of Gershon and the sons of Merari set forward, bearing the tabernacle.
(Numbers 10:17)

Reuben's standard comes next (10:18), with Simeon and Gad (10:19-20). After them, in verse 21, come the Kohathites, "bearing the sanctuary: and the other did set up the tabernacle against they came." Ephraim follows with Manasseh and Benjamin (10:22-24), and Dan "was the rearward of all the camps" (10:25).

Set that beside 2:17 and the tabernacle has moved. Chapter 2 puts it after the second rank, after Reuben. Chapter 10 has Gershon and Merari carrying the tabernacle right behind Judah, and the Kohathites with the sanctuary behind Reuben. Numbers 3 says what each family carried: Gershon the covering and hangings (3:25-26), Merari the boards, bars and pillars (3:36-37), Kohath "the ark, and the table, and the candlestick, and the altars" (3:31).

Then there's verse 33, which comes after the list of the march and after the exchange with Hobab:

And they departed from the mount of the Lord three days' journey: and the ark of the covenant of the Lord went before them in the three days' journey, to search out a resting place for them.
(Numbers 10:33)

The ark went before them, which means chapter 10 has the tabernacle's parts behind Judah and the sanctuary behind Reuben but the ark out ahead of everybody, while Numbers 3:31 lists the ark among Kohath's loads and 10:21 puts the Kohathites after Reuben. I can think of ways to line those up, such as the three days being a different stretch from the first day's march in verses 11 to 28, but the text doesn't choose one and I'd be supplying it.

Chapter 2 also calls the Levites "the camp of the Levites," one body in the middle. Chapter 10 breaks them up by family and scatters them down the line.

Numbers 3 says where the Levites pitch, too. Verse 38 has "Moses, and Aaron and his sons" encamping "before the tabernacle toward the east," the same side Judah's camp is on. The Gershonites pitch westward (3:23), the Kohathites southward (3:29), the Merari northward (3:35). Numbers 3 doesn't say why Judah has the east either.

Did they do it?

Verse 34 says yes, in one sentence: "And the children of Israel did according to all that the Lord commanded Moses: so they pitched by their standards, and so they set forward, every one after their families, according to the house of their fathers." Numbers 10:13 and 10:28 report that first move in the same terms, "according to the commandment of the Lord by the hand of Moses" and "according to their armies, when they set forward." After a chapter of names and numbers the verdict takes one verse.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which tribes camped on which side in Numbers 2?

Judah, Issachar and Zebulun are on the east (verses 3 to 9), and Reuben, Simeon and Gad on the south (10 to 16). Ephraim, Manasseh and Benjamin take the west (18 to 24), and Dan, Asher and Naphtali the north (25 to 31). Joseph has no camp under his own name, because his two sons Ephraim and Manasseh fill two of the twelve places.

Why did Judah go first?

The chapter says Judah's camp "shall first set forth" (verse 9) and gives no reason. Numbers 10:14 shows it happening. Any reason you hear is somebody's reading, not the text's.

What did the tribal standards look like?

The chapter doesn't say. Verse 2 has "his own standard" and "the ensign of their father's house," and that's all the description there is: no emblem, no color, no animal. Whatever you've seen in a picture, it didn't come from Numbers 2.

Were the Levites counted in the 603,550?

No. Verse 32 gives the total and verse 33 says "the Levites were not numbered among the children of Israel." Numbers 1:47 to 49 says the same thing at more length.

A question for you

Numbers 2:17 puts the tabernacle after Reuben, Numbers 10:17 puts it behind Judah, and Numbers 10:33 sends the ark out ahead of everyone. When you read those three together, which one do you treat as how Israel actually moved, and what do you do with the other two? I'd really like to know how you've settled it.

— D.

"Numbers 2: The Tabernacle Goes After Reuben and Before Ephraim"